Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgage rule: eight factors, the APR test, the 3% cap
Complete home loan kit, $49The Complete Home Loan Kit: FHA, VA, USDA and ConventionalFHA, VA, USDA and conventional: choose, qualify, close, 3 workbooks, instant access
See what is inside, $49On this topic: The Mortgage Compliance Study Guide (2026): ECOA, TRID, RESPA, SAFE Act and More, ebook, $39. Other titles: All workbooks

Since 2014 a lender must verify that you can actually repay a mortgage; a “qualified mortgage” is the lender’s reward for following a defined recipe, and your signal that the loan has no traps.
Quick answer
The ability-to-repay (ATR) rule, 12 CFR 1026.43, requires a creditor to make a reasonable, good-faith determination, from verified records, that you can repay a closed-end consumer loan secured by a dwelling, considering eight factors. A qualified mortgage (QM) is presumed to comply. In 2026 a General QM must have no negative amortization, interest-only or balloon feature, a term of 30 years or less, points and fees within 3% for loans of $137,958 or more, and an APR less than 2.25 points above the average prime offer rate for first liens of that size. QM payments must be computed at the maximum rate in the first five years (12 CFR 1026.43(e)(2)(iv)).
The Ability-to-Repay rule is the part of the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 written most directly in response to the stated-income, negative-amortization loans of the 2000s. It took effect on January 10, 2014 as section 1026.43 of Regulation Z. The idea is two-sided. Every lender making a covered mortgage must make a reasonable, good-faith determination that the borrower can repay it. A lender that makes a qualified mortgage — a loan without risky features, within a price and fee limit — receives legal protection from the claim that it failed to do so. The rule was substantially revised in 2021, when the old 43% debt-to-income ceiling was replaced by a pricing test.
Free 10-page PDF: Mortgage Pre-Approval Checklist (file tracker). Buyers and refinancing homeowners about to apply, who want to send a complete file once.
Get the free PDFCoverage and exemptions
ATR applies to closed-end consumer credit secured by a dwelling, including second homes and consumer-purpose loans on investment property you partly occupy. It does not apply to:
- home equity lines of credit and reverse mortgages;
- temporary or bridge loans with a term of 12 months or less, and the construction phase of a construction-to-permanent loan of 12 months or less;
- loans by state housing finance agencies, and certain loans by community development lenders, non-profits and emergency programs;
- business-purpose loans, which are outside Regulation Z altogether, including most hard money and investor loans;
- timeshare plans.
The eight underwriting factors
Outside the qualified mortgage path, a lender may use any reasonable underwriting method, but it must consider and verify, using third-party records, at least these eight items:
- current or reasonably expected income or assets (other than the value of the home itself);
- current employment status, if employment income is relied on;
- the monthly payment on the loan, calculated at the fully indexed rate on a fully amortizing schedule;
- the monthly payment on any simultaneous loan secured by the same property;
- monthly mortgage-related obligations: property taxes, insurance, HOA dues, ground rent;
- current debt obligations, alimony and child support;
- the monthly debt-to-income ratio or residual income;
- credit history.
“Verify” is the operative word: pay stubs, W-2s, tax transcripts, bank statements, a credit report. The rule does not set a maximum DTI for a non-QM loan, and since 2021 it does not prescribe a documentation standard either (the old Appendix Q was removed); it requires a reasonable judgment that can be defended.
What makes a loan a qualified mortgage
A General QM must have no negative amortization, interest-only period or balloon payment, a term of 30 years or less, and points and fees of no more than 3% of the total loan amount for loans at or above an indexed threshold (roughly $130,000, adjusted each January; higher percentages apply on a sliding scale to smaller loans, up to 8% below about $16,000). The lender must consider and verify income, assets, debts and DTI using the eight factors. And the price must fit: the APR may not exceed the average prime offer rate (APOR) for a comparable transaction by more than 2.25 percentage points on a first lien at or above the indexed loan-size threshold (higher spreads are allowed for smaller loans and subordinate liens). The 43% DTI cap that defined QM from 2014 to 2021 is gone, and the temporary “GSE patch” for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans expired with it.
The legal protection comes in two strengths. A QM with an APR less than APOR plus 1.5 points is a safe harbor: the borrower cannot claim an ATR violation. A QM priced between 1.5 and 2.25 points over APOR carries only a rebuttable presumption: the borrower may still prevail by showing that, at consummation, income left after the mortgage and debts was insufficient to meet living expenses. Other QM categories exist — small creditor portfolio QMs for lenders under an asset threshold holding loans in portfolio, balloon QMs in rural areas, and the 2021 seasoned QM for loans held 36 months with no more than two 30-day delinquencies and no 60-day delinquency.
One more feature tracks QM status: a prepayment penalty is permitted only on a fixed-rate qualified mortgage that is not a higher-priced loan, limited to three years and to 2% of the prepaid amount in years one and two and 1% in year three, and only if the lender also offered a loan without one.
What the rule does not do
It does not set a universal maximum DTI; a non-QM loan at 50% DTI is lawful if the lender documented its reasoning. It does not guarantee that a qualified mortgage is the cheapest loan or that you will be approved for one. It does not apply to the investor loans where “no income verification” is common, because those are business-purpose. And a loan labeled non-QM is not an illegal loan; it is a loan on which the lender carries the full burden of proving it checked your ability to pay.
Enforcement and remedies
The CFPB and prudential regulators examine for compliance. A borrower who proves an ATR violation may recover actual damages, statutory damages, and all finance charges and fees paid in the first three years of the loan, plus attorney’s fees. The statute of limitations is three years from the violation for an affirmative suit — but the violation may be raised as a defense by recoupment or set-off in a foreclosure at any time, which is the provision that makes the rule matter most to borrowers in trouble.
How to read your own loan through ATR/QM
Ask the lender whether the loan is a qualified mortgage, and if not, why. Look at the Loan Estimate for interest-only, balloon or negative amortization features and for a prepayment penalty. Compare the APR with the APOR for your lock week (the tables are published by the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council); a spread above 2.25 points means you are outside General QM and likely paying for risk the rule expects a lender to document. If a lender proposes to “state” income you do not have, or sets the payment on an introductory rate, that is the fact pattern the rule was written to stop. Details on how lenders calculate the ratios are in our DTI guide and affordability guide; the CFPB’s Regulation Z text is the primary source.
The eight ability-to-repay factors (12 CFR 1026.43(c)(2))
- Current or reasonably expected income or assets, other than the value of the dwelling that secures the loan.
- Current employment status, if employment income is relied on.
- The monthly payment on the loan, calculated under (c)(5).
- The monthly payment on any simultaneous loan the creditor knows or has reason to know of.
- The monthly payment for mortgage-related obligations (taxes, insurance, HOA dues).
- Current debt obligations, alimony and child support.
- The monthly debt-to-income ratio or residual income.
- Credit history.
Payment calculations: ATR versus QM
| Test | Interest rate used | Payment used | Section |
|---|---|---|---|
| General ability to repay | The fully indexed rate or any introductory rate, whichever is greater | Monthly, fully amortizing, substantially equal payments (special rules for balloon, interest-only and negative amortization loans) | 12 CFR 1026.43(c)(5) |
| Qualified mortgage underwriting | The maximum interest rate that may apply during the first five years after the first regular payment is due | Principal and interest repaying the balance over the remaining term at that rate (or the loan amount over the term), plus mortgage-related obligations | 12 CFR 1026.43(e)(2)(iv) |
General QM price limits for 2026
| Loan | First lien | Subordinate lien |
|---|---|---|
| $137,958 or more | 2.25 points or more | 3.5 points or more |
| $82,775 to $137,957 | 3.5 points or more | 3.5 points or more |
| Less than $82,775 | 6.5 points or more | 6.5 points or more |
| Manufactured home, first lien, under $137,958 | 6.5 points or more | — |
Points and fees limits for all QMs in 2026: 3% of the loan amount at $137,958 or more; $4,139 from $82,775 to $137,957; 5% from $27,592 to $82,774; $1,380 from $17,245 to $27,591; 8% below $17,245 (Federal Register 2025-22773, effective January 1, 2026).
Safe harbor or rebuttable presumption
A QM that is not a “higher-priced covered transaction” gets a conclusive safe harbor; a higher-priced QM gets only a rebuttable presumption of compliance (12 CFR 1026.43(e)(1)). A first-lien loan is higher-priced when its APR exceeds APOR by 1.5 points or more (3.5 for small-creditor and balloon QMs, and for subordinate liens) (12 CFR 1026.43(b)(4)). A seasoned QM, a fixed-rate first lien held in portfolio that performs for 36 months with no more than two 30-day delinquencies and no 60-day delinquency, gets the safe harbor regardless of price (12 CFR 1026.43(e)(7)).
Other qualified mortgage definitions
- Agency QMs: FHA, VA and USDA define their own QMs (24 CFR 201.7 and 203.19, 38 CFR 36.4300 and 36.4500, 7 CFR 3555.109), recognized in 12 CFR 1026.43(e)(4).
- Small creditor portfolio QMs (12 CFR 1026.43(e)(5)) and balloon-payment QMs (12 CFR 1026.43(f)) for qualifying small and rural creditors.
Which loans are exempt from ATR
12 CFR 1026.43(a) excludes HELOCs and timeshare loans entirely, and excludes from the ATR and QM requirements reverse mortgages, temporary or bridge loans of 12 months or less, the construction phase of 12 months or less of a construction-to-permanent loan, housing finance agency programs, and loans by certain community development, down payment assistance and nonprofit creditors. Business-purpose and investment-property loans are outside Regulation Z altogether. Since March 1, 2026, PACE financing is subject to ability-to-repay rules adapted to it (Federal Register 2024-30628).
Studying for a compliance review or the federal-law part of the SAFE test? The Mortgage Compliance Study Guide: ECOA, TRID, RESPA, SAFE Act ($39, PDF) puts these rules on one-page summaries with the 2026 thresholds and more than 100 original practice questions, each answered with its CFR section. It is not an NMLS-approved course.
Key points
- Dodd-Frank 2010; effective January 10, 2014 as Regulation Z 1026.43; rewritten in 2021 to replace the 43% DTI cap with an APR test.
- Exempt: HELOCs, reverse mortgages, bridge and construction loans of 12 months or less, HFA loans, business-purpose loans.
- Eight factors must be considered and verified with third-party records, including DTI or residual income and credit history.
- General QM: no negative amortization, interest-only or balloon, term 30 years or less, points and fees 3% or less (loans above an indexed threshold near $130,000).
- Price test: APR no more than APOR + 2.25 points on most first liens; safe harbor below APOR + 1.5, rebuttable presumption between.
- Prepayment penalties only on fixed-rate, non-higher-priced QMs: 3 years maximum, 2%/2%/1%, with a no-penalty alternative offered.
- Seasoned QM after 36 months of performance; small creditor and balloon QMs for portfolio lenders.
- Remedies: actual and statutory damages plus three years of finance charges; 3-year limit to sue, but recoupment in foreclosure at any time.
How ATR / QM applies to you
ATR/QM on a first mortgage: the HFA exemption and what the QM price test means for you
Nearly every first-time program produces a qualified mortgage, which is why the 43% DTI myth persists. The rules that actually shape a first loan are the eight ATR factors, FHA’s APR-based QM test, the 3% points-and-fees cap, and an exemption that covers HFA loans and DPA seconds.
- Document the gift and the DPA second early: any payment on a simultaneous second lien goes into the ATR ratio.
- Ask which QM test applies — FHA’s APR-plus-MIP test or the General QM price test — and whether the loan is safe harbor.
- Request the points-and-fees total if origination and broker charges on the Loan Estimate approach 3% of the loan.
- Do not treat 43% DTI as a wall; agency automated approvals commonly run higher with reserves and a solid credit profile.
Borrower profile: First-time home buyers.
QM pricing test on a conventional loan: how LLPAs push a 620 score toward the APOR line
A conforming loan is a Qualified Mortgage when its APR stays within 2.25 points of APOR and points and fees under 3%; DU and LPA approval no longer makes a loan QM by itself, and heavy LLPAs can erode the safe harbor.
- Ask the lender where your APR sits relative to APOR: under 1.5 points is safe harbor, 1.5 to 2.25 is rebuttable presumption and HPML with a five-year escrow.
- An AUS approval does not make the loan QM anymore; price, term, features and the 3% cap do.
- Expect DU and LPA to cap DTI at 50% even though the QM rule no longer has a DTI limit.
- Bona fide discount points are excluded from points and fees only within the APOR bands — that is why buydown depth may be limited.
Borrower profile: Conventional loan borrowers.
ATR/QM for VA loans: safe-harbor status, residual income and the IRRRL exception
VA wrote its own QM rule under the Dodd-Frank carve-out for federal agencies, so a VA purchase loan is a safe-harbor QM and an IRRRL is one only if it meets the seasoning and recoupment tests; the CFPB’s APR-over-APOR price test does not govern VA loans.
- Know that a VA purchase or cash-out loan is a safe-harbor QM under VA’s rule, with residual income as the core ability-to-repay check.
- Before any IRRRL, verify six payments made, 210 days elapsed and a recoupment period of 36 months or less — otherwise the loan only gets a rebuttable presumption.
- Check origination charges against the 3% points-and-fees cap; the funding fee is excluded, lender fees are not.
- Request the residual income figure and, if DTI exceeds 41%, the documented compensating factor.
Borrower profile: Veterans and service members.
ATR/QM for self-employed borrowers: third-party records, price-based QM and non-QM
Every consumer mortgage, QM or not, requires a reasonable, good-faith ability-to-repay determination built on third-party records. Since Appendix Q was repealed, the income definition comes from the lender’s own standards; general QM status turns on price, and bank-statement loans live in non-QM with the same verification duty.
- Tax transcripts, returns, bank statements and CPA-prepared financials are valid third-party records; your own spreadsheet is not.
- General QM is price-based since 2021: APR within 2.25 points of APOR, no risky features, points and fees under 3% — not a 43% DTI cap.
- Non-QM still requires a documented ATR analysis and may not include a prepayment penalty on a consumer loan.
- Ask whether the lender expects to season the loan into a QM after 36 months; it signals portfolio intent and pricing logic.
Borrower profile: Self-employed borrowers.
ATR/QM and investment property loans: why DSCR lenders never check your DTI
Section 1026.43 applies only to consumer-purpose loans, so DSCR, hard money and most rental loans carry no ability-to-repay duty, no QM pricing limits and no prepayment-penalty cap. Coverage ratio, reserves and exit plan replace the legal test.
- Run your own ability-to-repay test: stress the coverage ratio with two months of vacancy, a 10% rent drop and the fully indexed rate on any adjustable note.
- Read the prepayment clause with the QM rules in mind — a business-purpose note may charge penalties far beyond the 2%/1% three-year consumer cap.
- Confirm whether an agency investment loan is being underwritten as a consumer QM; if so, rental income, reserves and the prepayment ban follow agency rules.
- On hard money, ask whether interest accrues on disbursed funds or on the full commitment, and how many extension fees the note allows.
Borrower profile: Real estate investors.
ATR/QM for retirees: qualifying on assets and retirement income under the eight factors
The ability-to-repay rule lets a lender rely on assets instead of income and treats retirement as an employment status, not a defect; the loan becomes a qualified mortgage through pricing, not a fixed debt ratio, and a reverse mortgage is exempt altogether.
- Ask which factor carried the approval: documented income, assets or both.
- Provide award letters, 1099-R forms and statements early so verification does not stall the file.
- Ask whether the loan is a general QM, an agency-eligible QM or a non-QM asset-depletion product.
- Make sure HOA dues and taxes are inside the mortgage-related obligations figure.
Borrower profile: Retirees and senior borrowers.
ATR/QM for low-score borrowers: safe harbor, rebuttable presumption and non-QM
A subprime APR does not remove QM status but often pushes the loan from safe harbor into rebuttable presumption, and a recent bankruptcy or foreclosure is what sends you to non-QM — where the eight ATR factors still apply in full.
- Ask for the APR-to-APOR spread in writing: under 1.5 points is safe harbor QM, 1.5–2.25 is rebuttable presumption, above that is non-QM.
- On FHA, compare the APR with APOR plus 1.15 points plus the annual MIP rate to know which QM category you are in.
- Check total points and fees against the 3% cap on loans above roughly $135,000.
- On a non-QM loan after a recent bankruptcy or foreclosure, expect full income documentation — a lender skipping it is violating ATR, not doing you a favor.
- Look for balloon, interest-only or 40-year terms on non-QM offers; they are legal but change the exit strategy.
Borrower profile: Buyers with bad credit.
ATR/QM and ITIN loans: non-QM does not mean no rules, and what you must still document
A non-QM ITIN loan must still pass the ability-to-repay test with verified income and assets; the lender simply loses the legal presumption. Foreign-national loans on rentals are business-purpose and outside the rule entirely.
- Ask whether your loan is QM or non-QM and why; on an ITIN loan the answer is usually price, not your status.
- Bring two years of ITIN returns, transcripts or twelve to twenty-four months of bank statements; verification is required, not optional.
- Do not accept a “no income verification” offer on a home you will occupy; it is unlawful for consumer-purpose loans.
- On a vacation home financed through asset depletion, confirm the assets are verified and the calculation appears in the file.
- Keep closing documents; an ATR claim can be raised as a foreclosure defense and, affirmatively, within three years.
Borrower profile: Foreign nationals and ITIN borrowers.
ATR/QM and physician mortgages: contract income counts, but many doctor loans are non-QM
The ability-to-repay rule lets a lender rely on reasonably expected income such as a signed contract, so physician loans can comply. Whether a given loan is a qualified mortgage depends on its price and features, and a non-QM status shifts risk to the lender, not to you.
- Confirm the lender verified the contract from the employer, not from your own statement, and that contingencies have been cleared or accounted for.
- Ask which student loan payment was used in the determination and whether the loan is QM or non-QM.
- On an ARM, ask what payment the lender qualified you at; the QM method uses the highest rate possible in the first five years.
- Keep your own copy of the ATR file: contract, pay stubs, servicer statements. It is your evidence if the lender later claims a different basis.
Borrower profile: Physicians and licensed professionals.
ATR/QM with a hero DPA second: the HFA exemption, variable pay and the 3% fee test
HFA program loans and most DPA seconds are exempt from the ATR rule, but lenders still underwrite the first mortgage to Qualified Mortgage standards because they sell it. The real issues are documenting variable pay and keeping points and fees under the cap.
- HFA program loans and DPA seconds are ATR-exempt, yet the first mortgage is underwritten to QM because investors demand it.
- Deferred seconds add no monthly payment; forgivable seconds with a nominal payment and amortizing employer loans do.
- Bring a two-year overtime and shift-differential history; a one-year spike gets averaged down.
- On small GNND loans, watch the 3% points-and-fees cap and the APR-over-APOR safe harbor line.
Borrower profile: Teachers, first responders and “hero” buyers.
ATR/QM on USDA loans: USDA’s own qualified-mortgage rule, 29/41 ratios and GUS
Section 502 Guaranteed loans are qualified mortgages under USDA’s own definition rather than the CFPB’s price test; in practice the binding limits are USDA’s 29/41 ratios, GUS findings, and the 3% points-and-fees cap that excludes the guarantee fee.
- Ask whether the loan is a USDA QM with safe-harbor status and get the answer in writing.
- Add up origination, processing and broker fees against 3% of the loan; the guarantee fee does not count.
- Know whether your file is a GUS Accept or a manual underwrite; the ratio ceilings differ.
- Bring two years of seasonal or farm income records so the continuity test is not the reason for a decline.
- Treat “43% DTI” claims as an overlay, not a USDA or federal rule.
Borrower profile: Rural and USDA buyers.
ATR/QM on a second home: HOA dues count, projected vacation-rental income does not
ATR applies to a second home even though HOEPA and HPML rules do not, so the lender must verify income and count HOA dues and assessments; projected rental income from the property is excluded under agency rules and the reserve requirements are higher.
- Obtain the HOA budget and recent minutes; a scheduled special assessment will be added to your monthly obligations.
- Qualify on your own income — the rent you expect from the second home will not be counted, and a DSCR loan is not available for a home you will use.
- Count reserves early: two months of the second-home payment plus a percentage of balances on other financed properties.
- Ask whether the quoted loan is a qualified mortgage; if it is non-QM, any prepayment penalty in the offer is a red flag.
Borrower profile: Condo and second-home buyers.
Ability-to-Repay on a refinance: full-doc cash-out vs streamline QM exemptions
ATR applies to every consumer refinance, but agency rules make government streamlines qualified mortgages without income verification, while a conventional or cash-out refinance must pass the full eight-factor, third-party-verified test.
- On a government streamline, ask for the net tangible benefit worksheet; it is the document that makes the loan a QM without income verification.
- On a cash-out or conventional refinance, expect full third-party income verification and budget the time for tax transcripts.
- If your current loan is an ARM, interest-only or negative-amortization product, ask your own servicer about a non-standard-to-standard refinance.
- Ask whether the loan is a QM and whether it is safe harbor or rebuttable presumption; a non-QM label should come with a reason you understand.
Borrower profile: Refinancing homeowners.
Frequently asked questions
Is the 43% debt-to-income limit still part of the qualified mortgage rule?
No. From 2014 to early 2021 the General QM required a DTI of 43% or less. The CFPB replaced it with a price-based test: the APR may not exceed the average prime offer rate by more than 2.25 percentage points on most first-lien loans. Lenders must still consider and verify DTI or residual income, and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac keep their own DTI guidelines, typically up to 45% to 50%.
Is a non-QM loan a bad loan?
Not necessarily. Non-QM means the loan does not fit one of the qualified mortgage definitions, often because of bank-statement income documentation, a high DTI, interest-only payments or a larger fee. The lender still must determine your ability to repay using the eight factors and carries the full burden if challenged. Read the features and price carefully; the label tells you to ask more questions, not to walk away.
Does the ability-to-repay rule apply to hard money or DSCR investor loans?
Generally not. Loans primarily for business purposes, including most loans to buy, fix or hold rental property the borrower does not occupy, fall outside Regulation Z and therefore outside ATR/QM. That is why such lenders can underwrite on the property’s cash flow without verifying personal income. A consumer-purpose loan disguised as business-purpose remains covered, and the classification can be challenged on the facts.
What can I recover if a lender violated the ability-to-repay rule?
Actual damages, TILA statutory damages, all finance charges and fees paid during the first three years of the loan, and attorney’s fees, in a suit filed within three years of consummation. Beyond that period you may still raise the violation as a defense by recoupment or set-off if the lender or its successor forecloses or sues on the note. Consult a consumer attorney in your state about how courts there apply it.
What is the ATR/QM rule?
It is the Regulation Z rule at 12 CFR 1026.43. ATR requires lenders to verify and consider eight factors, including income, debts, DTI or residual income and credit history, before making a dwelling-secured consumer loan. QM is a category of loans with safer features and limited points and fees that is presumed to meet ATR, conclusively when the loan is not higher-priced.
Payment calculations for qualified mortgages must be based on what?
On the maximum interest rate that may apply during the first five years after the first regular payment is due, with principal and interest payments that repay the loan, and including mortgage-related obligations such as taxes and insurance (12 CFR 1026.43(e)(2)(iv)). The general ATR test instead uses the fully indexed rate or the introductory rate, whichever is greater.
What are the QM points and fees limits in 2026?
3% of the total loan amount for loans of $137,958 or more; $4,139 for $82,775 to $137,957; 5% for $27,592 to $82,774; $1,380 for $17,245 to $27,591; and 8% below $17,245. The CFPB adjusts these dollar figures every January 1 with the CPI.
Free 10-page PDF
Free: Mortgage Pre-Approval Checklist (file tracker)
Buyers and refinancing homeowners about to apply, who want to send a complete file once.
Get the free PDFYour state: conventional loans and mortgage law
The federal rules above apply everywhere; the rest depends on where the home is. For each state, one page gives the 2026 conforming limit of every county and the monthly cost of a conventional loan on the state median; the other gives the state layer: who closes the loan, recording taxes, prepayment, licensing, first-time buyer programs, hard money rules and foreclosure.
Sources
Related guides: Debt-to-income ratio limits by loan type — and how to lower yours, Rental cash flow, cap rate and DSCR: underwriting a rental before you borrow, Jumbo loans: requirements, rates and how they differ from conforming.