ATR/QM on a second home: HOA dues count, projected vacation-rental income does not

ATR applies to a second home even though HOEPA and HPML rules do not, so the lender must verify income and count HOA dues and assessments; projected rental income from the property is excluded under agency rules and the reserve requirements are higher.

The rule applies, and the association is in the payment

Unlike the high-cost and higher-priced rules, the ability-to-repay requirement covers consumer-purpose loans secured by any dwelling, so a vacation condo is fully inside it. The lender must consider and verify eight factors, and the “mortgage-related obligations” it must add to your payment expressly include homeowners association dues, special assessments, property taxes and insurance premiums — both the master policy charged through dues and your own HO-6. A pending assessment with a known payment schedule is generally added to the monthly obligation; an assessment merely under discussion is a judgment call, which is why underwriters read the association’s minutes. Automated agency approvals will allow a back-end ratio up to 50% on a second home, but many lenders overlay a 45% cap on non-owner-occupied files.

Income that counts and income that does not

Under the agencies’ rules a second home must not be rental property for qualifying purposes: you may rent it when you are away, but projected or even historical rent from that unit is not used in the ratio, and the loan is underwritten as if you carried the entire payment. Short-term rental income from a different property you already own can be considered when it is documented through tax returns or a sufficient history, under investment-property standards. Reserves are steeper than on a primary residence — typically two months of the full second-home payment, plus 2% to 6% of the unpaid balances on other financed properties depending on how many you have, with a cap of ten financed properties for agency eligibility.

Occupancy fraud is the abuse this profile attracts

Investor pricing is higher than second-home pricing, and investor loans need 15% down instead of 10%, so a buyer who intends to rent a unit 50 weeks a year has a financial reason to call it a second home. Lenders test the claim: distance from your primary residence, whether the project allows short-term rentals, listing sites, the occupancy affidavit, and post-closing checks. A misstatement is a default under the note, exposes the lender to repurchase and the borrower to federal false-statement liability. The ATR file itself shows the contradiction — a second home with no rental income counted — which is precisely why the lender will not let you have it both ways.

QM pricing and the non-warrantable detour

A second-home loan earns the general QM safe harbor when its APR is within 2.25 points of the average prime offer rate on loans above the indexed size threshold (about $130,000 in 2025) and points and fees stay under 3%. The second-home LLPA pushes the rate up but usually keeps the loan inside that band. A non-warrantable condo financed with interest-only or 40-year terms is not a QM at all; the lender still owes you a documented ATR analysis, and under the same rule a non-QM loan may not carry a prepayment penalty. DSCR products that qualify on the rent alone are business-purpose loans for investment property and are not an option for a home you will occupy.

What to check

Frequently asked questions

Can I use expected Airbnb income from the vacation condo to qualify?

Not on a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac second-home loan. Rental income from the subject property is excluded, and the loan must work on your other income after adding the full payment, HOA dues and any assessment. Some portfolio lenders consider projected short-term rental income under their own rules, usually with more down payment and higher pricing.

Is the 43% DTI limit still the test for a second-home loan?

No. The 43% cap was replaced in 2021 by a price-based test: a loan is generally a qualified mortgage when its APR sits within 2.25 points of the average prime offer rate. Agency automated underwriting may approve a second home up to a 50% back-end ratio, while many lenders apply their own lower ceiling on non-owner-occupied files.

The rule in full: Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgage rule (ATR/QM). The borrower profile: Condo and second-home buyers. Related guides: Conventional loans for condos and second homes: the extra rules · PMI removal: the 80% request, the 78% automatic cancellation, and the appraisal route · Debt-to-income ratio limits by loan type — and how to lower yours · How much house can I afford? The math lenders actually use.

Other federal rules for condo and second-home buyers

TILA / Reg Z · RESPA · TRID disclosures · ECOA · Fair Housing Act · HMDA · SAFE Act / NMLS · HOEPA · HPA / PMI · Servicing rules · FCRA · Flood insurance · MARS rule · SCRA · LO compensation

ATR / QM for other borrowers

First-time buyers · Conventional borrowers · Veterans · Self-employed · Investors · Retirees · Bad credit · Foreign nationals · Physicians · Heroes · Rural buyers · Refinancing

Sources

Get the free conventional loan guide (PDF) — plus your state’s edition

A short, printable guide built from public sources — agency programs, state statutes, federal rules — with the figures already worked out for your state. Download now; we email you the link so you can find it again.

Free. No fees, ever. Claude Loan is an information site — not a lender, broker or advisor. Have a specific question? Add it below — a real person answers in plain English within 48 hours, free.