Cart 0

Rental cash flow, cap rate and DSCR: underwriting a rental before you borrow

Published by Claude Loan (Tech-Bharat)Edited by Clément LacailleSources: Fannie Mae, Freddie MacLast updated 7 min readHow we research

Weathered two-story farmhouse in need of repair
Weathered two-story farmhouse in need of repair. Photo: Nicholas A. Tonelli from Northeast Pennsylvania, USA, CC BY 2.0

A rental is a small business whose only product is rent, and most of the ways it loses money never appear in the listing. Underwriting a property yourself, before a lender does, is what separates an investment from a mortgage payment you happen to make on someone else’s house.

Four numbers, in order

Every rental analysis walks the same ladder, and skipping a rung is where beginners go wrong.

  1. Gross scheduled rent — what the property would collect if every unit were rented every month at market.
  2. Effective gross income — gross rent minus vacancy and credit loss.
  3. Net operating income (NOI) — effective gross income minus operating expenses. Debt service is never an operating expense; that exclusion is what makes NOI comparable between a cash buyer and a leveraged one.
  4. Cash flow — NOI minus debt service. This is the number that lands in your account.

A worked pro forma

A duplex at a $250,000 purchase price, both units at $1,250 a month, financed with 20% down and a $200,000 loan at an illustrative 7% over 30 years. Annual figures, rounded.

LineBasisAmount
Gross scheduled rent$2,500 × 12$30,000
Vacancy and credit loss6% of gross−$1,800
Effective gross income$28,200
Property taxes1.1% effective rate, illustrative−$2,750
Insurancelandlord policy−$1,800
Repairs and maintenance8% of effective gross−$2,256
Capital reserve (roof, HVAC, turnovers)6% of effective gross−$1,692
Property management9% of collected rent−$2,538
Owner-paid water, sewer, trash, lawn, snowcommon on a duplex−$1,500
Accounting, licenses, leasing, marketing−$600
Net operating income$15,064
Debt service (principal and interest)$1,331 a month−$15,972
Cash flow before income tax−$908

At these assumptions the property loses about $76 a month. Nothing in the table is pessimistic: 6% vacancy is roughly three weeks a year, and the reserves are the cost of a roof and a furnace spread over the years before they fail. The payment itself is not the variable people expect either — our $200,000 at 7% payment table shows what each rate does to the same loan, and a point of rate moves this deal by more than the entire management fee.

The three ratios, and what each one hides

  • Cap rate = NOI ÷ price. Here $15,064 ÷ $250,000 = 6.0%. It measures the property, not the deal: it ignores your financing entirely, which is exactly why it is the right tool for comparing two buildings and the wrong tool for deciding whether you can afford one.
  • Cash-on-cash return = annual cash flow ÷ cash invested. With $50,000 down plus roughly $7,000 of closing costs and $5,000 of make-ready, that is −$908 ÷ $62,000, or about −1.5%. Negative, and the honest way to say so.
  • Debt service coverage ratio = NOI ÷ debt service. $15,064 ÷ $15,972 = 0.94. Below 1.0 means operations do not cover the loan.
House lifted on cribbing while it is elevated, New Orleans
House lifted on cribbing while it is elevated, New Orleans. Photo: Infrogmation, CC BY-SA 4.0

The DSCR your lender computes is not the DSCR above

This is the trap worth the price of the whole exercise. Most DSCR lenders do not use your operating pro forma. They divide gross rent by PITIA — principal, interest, taxes, insurance and association dues — and nothing else. On the same duplex: $2,500 of rent against a PITIA of about $1,710 ($1,331 principal and interest, $229 taxes, $150 insurance) gives a lender DSCR of roughly 1.46, comfortably above the 1.20 to 1.25 minimum many programs post.

So the property qualifies easily for a loan on which it loses money every month. Vacancy, management, maintenance and capital reserves — four line items worth almost $8,000 a year here — simply do not appear in the lender’s formula. Passing underwriting is not evidence that a rental works. The product comparison sits in DSCR loans vs conventional for investment property.

Agency financing measures it differently again. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide rental income rules take the gross rent from a lease or an appraiser’s rent schedule and count 75% of it, the remaining quarter treated as absorbed by vacancy and maintenance. That 25% haircut is a qualification convention, not an expense budget — real operating costs on an older building routinely exceed it.

Where the rules of thumb break

The duplex above rents for exactly 1% of its price per month, so it passes the famous 1% rule — and still loses money. The rule was a screening shortcut from an era of much cheaper debt and much cheaper insurance; at current rates it filters properties into the “worth analyzing” pile and nothing more. The 50% rule (operating expenses ≈ half of gross rent) holds up better: here the expenses are $13,136 against $30,000 of gross rent, about 44%, which is on the low side and a signal to check whether the insurance and tax numbers are current rather than the seller’s.

Stress the deal before you buy it

Run the pro forma again with the four shocks that actually happen, one at a time and then together.

  • Two months empty between tenants on one unit: about $2,500 of lost rent plus turnover costs.
  • Insurance up 30% at renewal: −$540 a year, and in coastal or wildfire markets far more.
  • One capital item — a $9,000 roof — which is exactly what the reserve line exists to absorb, and does not, in year two.
  • A higher rate at refinance if you are exiting a short-term loan into permanent financing. A point of rate on $200,000 is roughly $135 a month.

A deal that survives all four is a rental. One that only works with full occupancy, self-management and no reserve is a bet on nothing going wrong for a decade. The way most investors close the gap is not better spreadsheet assumptions but a lower basis: buying below market and renovating, then refinancing into permanent debt at a value you created rather than paid for. That is the whole logic of the BRRRR refinance, and it is why the acquisition price does more work than any operating line in the table.

Claude Loan is an information site, not a lender, broker, property manager or financial adviser. Every figure above is illustrative and rounded — tax rates, insurance, rents and expense ratios vary enormously by market and by building — and none of it is an offer of credit or a projection of returns. Build the pro forma with quotes for your actual property, and check the lending rules where it sits on our hard money state pages.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good cash-on-cash return on a rental?

There is no standard, and anyone quoting one is describing their own market. What matters more is whether the return compensates you for the risk and the work compared with a passive alternative, and whether it survives the stress tests above. A high return built on a 3% vacancy assumption and no capital reserve is an arithmetic result, not an investment.

Should I include property management if I plan to self-manage?

Include it. Self-managing converts a cost into your unpaid labor rather than eliminating it, and the property has to be sellable to someone who will hire a manager. If the deal only works because you answer the phone at 2 a.m. for free, that is worth knowing before closing rather than after.

Why does my lender approve a loan the property cannot support?

Because most investor programs measure gross rent against PITIA and stop there. Vacancy, maintenance, capital expenditure and management are outside the formula. Underwriting approval answers the lender’s question about its collateral, not your question about cash flow.

Does appreciation make negative cash flow acceptable?

It can, and it is how a great deal of real estate wealth has been built — but it is a forecast rather than a fact, and the shortfall has to be funded from somewhere every month in the meantime. The practical test is whether you could carry the deficit through a year of vacancy or a major repair without selling.

How much should I set aside for repairs and capital expenditure?

Common practice is to reserve separately for routine maintenance and for the big items that fail on a schedule — roof, heating and cooling, water heater, flooring, turnovers — often in the range of 5% to 10% of collected rent each. Older buildings and deferred maintenance push it higher; a fully renovated property in its first years, lower.

Does a DSCR loan report on my personal credit?

Usually not when closed in an entity, though the lender pulls your credit and requires a personal guarantee in most cases.

Do lenders charge more for out-of-state borrowers?

Usually not for the borrower’s location as such. Pricing follows the property’s state, the asset type and your track record. What can change is the file: some lenders want a local contractor of record, a property management agreement in place before funding, or slightly lower leverage on a first project in an unfamiliar market.

What DSCR do lenders require?

Most want 1.0 to 1.25; some go below 1.0 with 30%+ down and a higher rate. Above 1.25 earns better pricing.

Sources

Related: Hard money exit strategies: sell, refinance, or hold — and the plan B, Blanket loans: putting several rentals under one mortgage. Hub: Hard money.

More hard money guides

Get the free hard money investor guide (PDF) — plus your state’s edition

Get the PDF edition for your state: key facts, the rules that apply, the numbers worked on the state median, and a step-by-step checklist. It downloads the moment you submit, and the link lands in your email too.

The guide is free, no fees. Claude Loan is an information site — not a lender, broker or advisor. Your free guide link appears as soon as you submit. A question is optional: we cannot give advice on your file. For that, a HUD-approved housing counselor is free.

Prefer to talk to a licensed lender?

Our guides explain the rules; a loan officer can quote you an actual rate and tell you what you qualify for. Pick your situation and we will pass your request to up to three partner lenders or brokers licensed in your state (check any of them on NMLS Consumer Access). Free, no obligation.

Step 1 of 2: your project