Cart 0

Rent vs buy calculator: which path leaves you with more, year by year

Complete home loan kit, $49The Complete Home Loan Kit: FHA, VA, USDA and ConventionalCheck your own file against the 2026 limits: qualifying income, DTI, cash to close and the date your PMI can end, worksheet by worksheet. 3 workbooks, instant access

See what is inside, $49

Buying wins or loses depending on how long you stay, how fast prices and rents rise and what your savings would earn otherwise — none of which anyone can know in advance. So this calculator does not hide those assumptions: it builds both paths month by month and compares what each leaves you with. The owner’s side is the home’s value minus selling costs minus the loan balance; the renter’s side is the down payment and buying costs invested instead, plus or minus the monthly difference in cost. The mortgage rate starts at this week’s 30-year average, 7.18%.

Every growth rate, return, maintenance and cost percentage above is an assumption chosen to illustrate the mechanics, not a forecast or a market average. Change them; the answer is often decided by them.

Rentingcomes out ahead after 7 years by about $36,313 of net worth, with these assumptions
Owner net equity after selling$133,394 (value minus 6% selling costs minus loan balance)
Renter portfolio$169,707 (down payment and buying costs invested at 4.0%, plus or minus the monthly difference)
Year buying pulls aheadnot within 7 years
Total paid to own$341,256 (down payment, buying costs, payments, tax, insurance, upkeep)
Total rent paid$202,289
YearCost to ownRentOwner equityRenter portfolio
Year 1$3,380/mo$2,200/mo$30,812$68,546
Year 2$3,400/mo$2,266/mo$46,224$85,205
Year 3$3,421/mo$2,334/mo$62,267$101,962
Year 4$3,442/mo$2,404/mo$78,971$118,806
Year 5$3,464/mo$2,476/mo$96,369$135,722
Year 6$3,487/mo$2,550/mo$114,498$152,695
Year 7$3,510/mo$2,627/mo$133,394$169,707

Appreciation, rent growth and investment return are your assumptions, not forecasts; change them to see how sensitive the answer is. Income-tax effects are left out: the mortgage interest deduction helps only if you itemize.

Worked example with the default numbers above; turn on JavaScript to recompute with yours.

The formula

Each month: cost to own = principal & interest + tax + insurance + maintenance + HOA + PMI (until 78% LTV); renter portfolio = portfolio × (1 + return ÷ 12) + (cost to own − rent).
At year end: home value × (1 + price growth); rent × (1 + rent increase).
Owner net equity = value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance. Renter portfolio starts with the down payment + buying costs. Buying wins in the first year owner equity ≥ renter portfolio.

A fair comparison: same cash, two paths

The common mistake is to compare a rent check with a mortgage payment. They are not the same kind of money: part of the mortgage payment repays principal, which you keep, while the rest — interest, taxes, insurance, upkeep — is gone, like rent. And the down payment does not vanish when you rent: it stays in your account, where it can earn something. This calculator therefore follows the same household with the same cash down two paths. On the buying path, the cash becomes a down payment and closing costs, and every month you pay the full cost of owning. On the renting path, the same cash is invested, and every month the renter invests the difference when owning costs more than renting (or draws on the investments when renting costs more). After the number of years you choose, it compares the owner’s net equity if the house were sold with the renter’s portfolio.

The assumptions that decide the answer

  • How long you stay. Buying has heavy one-time costs at both ends: closing costs when you buy and selling costs (agent commissions, transfer taxes, concessions) when you leave. They take years of equity growth to recover, which is why buying often loses over two or three years and wins over ten. The “year buying pulls ahead” line answers this directly.
  • Price growth versus investment return. The owner earns the price growth on the whole house with a small down payment (leverage); the renter earns the return on a smaller sum. Small changes in either swing the result: try price growth at 0%, 3% and 5% to see the range.
  • Rent growth. A mortgage payment is fixed while rent usually rises, so the gap tends to narrow over time in the owner’s favor — unless your rent is protected or below market.
  • Maintenance. Renters do not pay for a new roof or water heater; owners do. The default of 1% of the value a year is an illustrative placeholder; older homes can cost more.

What the calculator leaves out, deliberately

Income taxes. Mortgage interest and property taxes are deductible only if you itemize instead of taking the standard deduction. Because that depends on your whole tax situation, the calculator ignores them (IRS Publication 936 explains the mortgage interest deduction). Renter’s insurance and moving costs, both small, and the non-financial side: stability, control over the home, the freedom to move for a job. A result within a few thousand dollars either way is a tie; decide on those.

Using the result well

Start with your real rent and a price you could actually buy at (pick a state to load its approximate median price and tax rate), then use realistic numbers for your situation: your own expected years in the area matter more than any default. If buying wins only under optimistic growth, it is a bet, not a plan. If it wins even at zero price growth, the purchase is driven by rent savings and principal repayment, which is sturdier. Before deciding, check what the house would cost each month in full with the mortgage payment calculator, what price your income supports with the affordability calculator, and the cash you would need at closing with the closing cost calculator. First-time buyer programs in your state can lower the cash needed; see first-time home buyer programs.

Free printable worksheet

Do the same arithmetic on paper, with your Loan Estimate next to it:

home
Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0 (credit)

Guides that go with this calculator

Other mortgage calculators

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy a house right now?

It depends on how long you will stay, your rent, the price and the rate — not on the calendar. The calculator shows the year buying overtakes renting with your numbers; if you expect to move before that year, renting usually leaves you with more.

How many years do you need to stay to make buying worth it?

Enough for price growth and principal repayment to cover the closing costs of buying and the costs of selling. With the default assumptions the calculator shows that break-even year; change the price growth and selling costs to see how sensitive it is.

Is renting throwing money away?

No more than mortgage interest, property tax, insurance and maintenance are. Rent buys housing; the owner’s equivalent costs buy housing too. The difference is principal repayment and price growth on the owner’s side versus investment returns on the renter’s side, which is exactly what this calculator compares.

Does the rent vs buy calculator include the mortgage interest tax deduction?

No. The deduction helps only owners who itemize rather than take the standard deduction. Leaving it out keeps the comparison neutral; if you itemize, buying looks somewhat better than shown.

Sources

All tools: mortgage calculators. This week’s rates: mortgage rates.

Get the free first-time home buyer guide (PDF) — plus your state’s edition

A printable PDF with the programs, the state rules, the worked numbers and a checklist — the same facts as this site, organized so you can act on them. Enter your details and the download opens immediately; we also email you the link.

The guide is free, no fees. Claude Loan is an information site — not a lender, broker or advisor. Your free guide link appears as soon as you submit. A question is optional: we cannot give advice on your file. For that, a HUD-approved housing counselor is free.

Prefer to talk to a licensed lender?

Our guides explain the rules; a loan officer can quote you an actual rate and tell you what you qualify for. Pick your situation and we will pass your request to up to three partner lenders or brokers licensed in your state (check any of them on NMLS Consumer Access). Free, no obligation.

Step 1 of 2: your project