Cart 0

Reconsideration of value request: template for challenging a low appraisal

Published by Claude Loan (Tech-Bharat)Edited by Clément LacailleLast updated 2 min readHow we research

A reconsideration of value (ROV) asks the lender to send your evidence to the appraiser and request a second look. It works when it points to factual errors or better comparable sales, not when it simply asks for a higher number.

The rules in short

  • Fannie Mae lenders must have a borrower-initiated ROV process and disclose it when they give you the appraisal; only one borrower-initiated ROV per appraisal (B4-1.3-12).
  • Required content: names, address, appraisal effective date, appraiser name, date of the request, the deficiencies, up to five comparables with sources, and why they support the request.
  • FHA: Mortgagee Letter 2024-07’s ROV policy was rescinded by ML 2025-08 on March 19, 2025; ask the FHA lender for its written process.
  • You are entitled to a copy of the appraisal promptly, or three business days before closing at the latest (12 CFR 1002.14).

Before you write: get the report and the process

Lenders must give you a copy of every appraisal on a first-lien home loan “promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation,” whichever is earlier (Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14(a)(1)). On a Fannie Mae loan, the lender “must provide a disclosure to the borrower outlining the ROV process when the appraisal report is provided,” and that disclosure “must make it clear that only one borrower-initiated ROV is permitted per appraisal” (Selling Guide B4-1.3-12). One shot: make it complete.

What Fannie Mae says the request must contain

  • Borrower name(s), property address, effective date of the appraisal, appraiser name and date of the ROV request.
  • Identification and description of unsupported, inaccurate or deficient areas in the report.
  • Additional data, information or comparable properties, “not to exceed five,” with their data sources (for example the MLS number).
  • An explanation of why the new data supports the ROV.

The lender then reviews your request, may ask you for more information, and sends a standardized request to the appraiser, whose answer comes back in a revised report “that includes commentary on conclusions regardless of the outcome.” Fannie Mae’s process also covers values believed to reflect unacceptable or discriminatory appraisal practices.

FHA and other loans

For FHA loans, HUD’s uniform ROV policy in Mortgagee Letter 2024-07 no longer applies: Mortgagee Letter 2025-08, dated March 19, 2025, rescinded MLs 2024-07, 2024-16 and 2021-27 “to restore previous policy.” Ask the FHA lender for its written ROV procedure. For VA and other loans, ask the lender in writing how it handles a reconsideration request.

The template

Template: Reconsideration of value request

REQUEST FOR RECONSIDERATION OF VALUE

Date of this request: [date]
To: [loan officer name], [lender name]
Loan number: [number]
Borrower(s): [full name(s)]
Property address: [address]
Appraisal effective date: [date]    Appraiser: [name]    Appraised value: $[amount]

I received the appraisal on [date] and request a reconsideration of value under the lender's ROV process.

1. Unsupported, inaccurate or deficient areas
a) [Example: gross living area reported as 1,640 sq ft. County record and attached floor plan show 1,820 sq ft above grade.]
b) [Example: no time adjustment on comparable 3, which closed eight months before the effective date while the report describes the market as increasing.]

2. Comparable sales not considered (no more than five)
Comp A: [address], closed [date], $[price], [sq ft], [beds/baths], [distance], source: MLS #[number]. More similar than comparable [number] because [reason].
Comp B: [same details]
[Comp C to E if needed]

3. Why this information supports a reconsideration
[Two or three sentences linking the errors and comparables to the value conclusion.]

I am not asking for a specific value. I ask that the appraiser consider this information and explain the conclusion in a revised report.

Please confirm receipt and the expected response time.

[Name]   [Signature]   [Phone]   [Email]
Attachments: [list]

How to make it work

  • Facts first. Wrong square footage, bedroom count, lot size, missing garage or finished basement: attach the county record, a floor plan or permit.
  • Better comparables. Closed sales, close in time, distance and features, that the appraiser did not use. Active listings carry little weight.
  • No pressure on value. Ask for a reconsideration of evidence, not a target number; lenders must keep appraiser independence (12 CFR 1026.42).

If the value stands, your options are in what to do about an appraisal gap; the full playbook, with comparables worksheets and gap-clause math, is in our Low Appraisal and Appraisal Gap Playbook.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a reconsideration of value take?

Fannie Mae requires lenders to define turn-time expectations in their ROV policy; ask for that time when you submit, and plan your contract deadlines around it.

Can I order a second appraisal instead?

A second appraisal is a lender decision. When one is obtained, Fannie Mae expects the lender to rely on the most reliable report, not the highest.

Can the value go down after an ROV?

The appraiser reviews the evidence and states a conclusion; it usually stays or rises when errors are corrected, but the request does not guarantee a change.

Columned federal building with American flags in Washington, D.C.
Photo: David Samuel, User:Hellodavey1902, CC BY-SA 3.0 (credit)

Other letter templates

These templates are general information, not legal advice. Adapt them to your facts, keep a copy and proof of delivery, and follow any form or address your lender or servicer requires.

Sources

Back to all mortgage letter templates.

Get the free first-time home buyer guide (PDF) — plus your state’s edition

The guide gathers what matters for your state on a few printable pages: programs and limits, the statutes that set the timeline, a worked example and a checklist. Instant download, link sent to your inbox as well.

The guide is free, no fees. Claude Loan is an information site — not a lender, broker or advisor. Your free guide link appears as soon as you submit. A question is optional: we cannot give advice on your file. For that, a HUD-approved housing counselor is free.

Prefer to talk to a licensed lender?

Our guides explain the rules; a loan officer can quote you an actual rate and tell you what you qualify for. Pick your situation and we will pass your request to up to three partner lenders or brokers licensed in your state (check any of them on NMLS Consumer Access). Free, no obligation.

Step 1 of 2: your project